SCOTUS Declines to Hear Challenge to Maryland’s ‘Sensitive Places’ Gun Law

 


The U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) on Monday turned away a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on where licensed gun owners can carry firearms, leaving in place a state law that bars concealed weapons from a wide array of public venues.

By denying review in the consolidated litigation involving Novotny v. Moore and Kipke v. Moore, the justices left intact a January 2026 ruling from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit that upheld the bulk of Maryland’s post-Bruen firearms framework.

Enacted in response to the Supreme Court’s 2022 New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen decision — which established the right to carry firearms in public for self-defense — Maryland’s statute prohibits individuals with wear-and-carry permits from bringing guns into locations designated as “sensitive places.”

Under the upheld provisions, firearms are banned on mass transit, in healthcare facilities, at public demonstrations or within 1,000 feet of them, in establishments that sell alcohol for on-site consumption (such as bars and restaurants), in stadiums, museums and casinos, and across tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land.

 

While the high court’s order list offered no majority explanation for declining the appeal, Justice Clarence Thomas issued a separate statement respecting the denial of certiorari that signaled “deep skepticism toward the breadth of Maryland’s restrictions,” according to the SCOTUS blog.

Thomas, the author of the 2022 Bruen opinion, wrote that he highly doubts every category in Maryland’s statute aligns with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation, noting that early American legislatures recognized only a narrow set of sensitive locations such as legislative assemblies, polling places and courthouses.

Nevertheless, Thomas agreed with the decision not to take up the appeal at this stage, explaining that because each challenged Maryland statute implicates a distinct tradition, the plaintiffs’ sweeping challenge would complicate Supreme Court review. He also added that the justices should instead revisit the scope of state authority over sensitive places in a “future, more narrowly focused case.”

 

In defending the law before the Fourth Circuit and the Supreme Court, Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown argued that prohibiting guns in confined, crowded, and vulnerable public spaces falls within a longstanding American regulatory tradition.

Although the Fourth Circuit had previously invalidated Maryland’s default rule barring firearms on all private property open to the public without the owner’s express consent — a position echoed when SCOTUS struck down a similar Hawaii private-property restriction in Wolford v. Lopez earlier this year — the appellate court concluded that Maryland’s bans in public-facing venues and state lands were constitutionally sound.

Monday’s decision leaves Maryland’s restrictions fully enforceable, lifting temporary stays that had paused enforcement of the bans on alcohol-serving establishments and public demonstrations while the petition was pending.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Taylor Swift: 'White supremacy is repulsive. There is nothing worse'

Tulsi Gabbard says impeachment of Trump would be 'terribly divisive' for country

Dr. Vladimir Zelenko has now treated 699 coronavirus patients with 100% success

ORIGIN OF THE AKAN - Onyeji Nnaji

GARDEN OF EDEN FOUND IN WEST AFRICA - Onyeji Nnaji

EGYPTIANS LAMBAST NIGERIAN FOOTBALLERS OVER ‘FREQUENT’ PROTESTS

Marine Charged for Facebook Comments Gets Hearing Date

TYPES OF PREPOSITION - Onyeji Nnaji

THE ORIGIN AND HISTORY OF NSUKKA by Onyeji Nnaji